2. Dom Dwyer
Orlando City Stats: 67 Games, 24 Goals, 9 Assists
Bit of a hot take to put Dwyer above Dike, but given his longevity, he gets the nod. The trade to bring Dwyer back to Orlando was the worst of its kind in Major League Soccer history and Dwyer greatly underperformed after the move. But at the same time, he did score over 20 goals and was a face for the franchise in a dark time.
Dom Dwyer was not that good for Orlando City in the MLS era, but he is, or at least should be, a beloved in club history. He played a role back in the USL days, and even when thing were bad, Dwyer genuinely loved the city and the club and that goes a long way, at least for me.