2. Chris Mueller
Years w/ Orlando City: 3
Stats: 21 G, 24 A
This one stings.
The Money Badger is one of the most productive players in Orlando City history. He holds club records for assists and appearances and is top five in goals. Mueller is also one of a few Orlando players to ever represent the United States Men's National Team. From an exciting rookie season to his breakout 2020 campaign, Mueller became one of the faces of the club and one of the most beloved figures in the team's history.
And then he left. I don't blame Chris Mueller for wanting to leave and go to Hibernian. Chase the bag, control your career; I get it. But the fallout of that move and porous end to his time in Orlando have soured his legacy here. I hope for the sake of all parties, there'll be some kind of reunion (on the field or some kind of off-field event) to patch things up and recognize Cash for the history-making legend he is.